Lower Your Labor Expenses By Reducing Time Card Fraud

employee timecard fraud
Avatar photo


HR tech that powers small businesses. Get in, get the job done and keep your business moving with an easy to use solution for time, HR and benefits.

Employee Time Theft

Time theft and inaccurate timekeeping of employee hours can cost companies dearly. There are times when the incorrect hours reported by an employee are honest mistakes but there are also instances when employees are deliberately trying to get paid for time that they did not work. These dishonest occurrences are actually time theft and can be just as dangerous to your bottom line as the electronics department cashier who walks out with a pair of $80 headphones under her coat or a roofer who reports a $400 nail gun as stolen when he actually pawned it. The various methods used generally fall into four categories.

1. “Buddy Punching”

Aptly named buddy punching is when one employee punches the time clock for another employee who isn’t actually at work. Maybe they make it look like their friend arrived on time when they didn’t, stayed later than they actually did, or took a shorter lunch break. This type of time theft can even happen when hours are reported in an online portal because employees can simply share their personal login information.

2. Falsifying Punch Times

This type of time theft occurs when an employee deliberately misreports their hours at work. When hours at a business are reported manually, this type of stealing time is more likely to occur (both intentionally and unintentionally). No matter the motivation behind this, overestimating even a few minutes each day can really add up.

Let’s say you have 20 employees who add what they consider to be a negligible 8 minutes of time each day that they actually were not working. The math is simple. If they average $10/hour, you will end up overpaying the following:

$133 each week

$533 each month

$6900 each year

Any small business owner could think of a hundred better things to do with that almost $7000 each year. Advertise more! Upgrade equipment! Expand your social media presence! Invest in an automated Workforce Management System and scanning time clock and still have money left over for a nice vacation!

3. On The Clock But Not Working

Some employees feel that simply punching in is the important part of getting paid, instead of actually working during those hours. The ubiquity of smartphones and the internet in the workplace make it difficult for many employees to resist sending a quick text to family members, making a personal call, or surfing the web for fun or to shop online. There is a myriad of ways to use company time for personal business. (Hopefully, everyone who is reading this blog post during work hours is doing important manager-authorized research on ways to eliminate time theft at your company.)

4. Extended Breaks

Not only are breaks important because they are mandated by law in many states, breaks can be the perfect solution for employees who need to do a few minutes of personal business on company time. An employee who is making an eye doctor appointment when they should be working can be reminded that these activities are better done during their break. However, employers who offer regular breaks without having their employees clock out may be setting themselves up for frequent time theft by employees. Breaks are easy to stretch out an extra five or ten minutes, and this can happen multiple times a day with multiple employees! The expense increases surprisingly fast due to exponential math: number of occurrences multiplied by total number of minutes stolen multiplied by number of employees.

So what can employers do to eliminate employees stealing time from the workplace? Good management, thorough training, and implementing an automated time and attendance system at your business are the best ways to reduce time theft.

Be Clear About What You Expect From Your Employees

Employees run the gamut from highly self-motivated to those in need of guidance at every turn. Having clear expectations from day one will help employees know how best to use their time, even when there is no immediate need for their primary duties.

For example, in retail settings, managers should tell workers which tasks should be completed when customers aren’t requesting their assistance. A statement such as, “If there are no customers that need your help, try to tidy up the check-out area or do a quick walk-through of the sales floor and straighten up items on the shelves.” In a manufacturing environment, the manager can create a hierarchy of duties that workers can perform when a machine is down, such as stocking materials or helping the shipping department with their constant backlog.  Having a list of alternative tasks where employees can see them can also be helpful to keep workers productive while they are on the clock.

Also, stress the seriousness of time card fraud. Some employees might not think it’s a big deal to let their friend leave early and clock out for them later. Maybe their friend promises they’ll make up the time next pay period and their reason for doing so seems legitimate. But employers should be clear that this is fraud and they are essentially stealing from the company.

If there is a central area where employees clock in, it would be helpful and appropriate to hang a sign reminding them to be honest and accurate with their time reporting.

Make sure break time is well-defined. Does the break start when they leave their desk or register? Or does it only count when they are in the break room? By the way, a sign with the break policy spelled out would be a wonderful decoration for any break room!

Have Well-Defined Consequences for Time Clock Infractions and Follow Through

Whenever company rules are broken and no consequences occur, it is assumed by employees that that rule isn’t very important. This doesn’t mean that every consequence needs to be severe, but there should be a clear program of progressive discipline.

Progressive discipline allows employers to intervene in conduct problems such as time card fraud with a range of responses that graduate from mild to harsh. A common sequence of these progressing responses is:

1. Verbal Warning

2. Written Warning

3. Suspension

4. Termination

These graduated levels to discipline allow managers to step in early-on, before a problem becomes a fireable offense. They can even foster better communication between employees and management. Progressive discipline is also an invaluable way to keep a record of issues if an employee does need to be terminated.

Get A Timekeeping System That Protects You From Time Theft

Automated Workforce Management systems are the best way to manage time and attendance at your company and prevent time card fraud. The SwipeClock Workforce Management Suite includes TimeWorksPlus. TimeWorksPlus is a cloud-based time and attendance solution that allows for much more accurate timekeeping than manual systems.

The first step in eliminating time theft is accurately capturing employee shift start and end times. TimeWorksPlus provides businesses with a variety of ways for their workers to punch in and out. Employees can log time with one of our plug-and-play verification time clocks or on their tablets, mobile phones, laptops, or desktop computers. This eliminates the need for employees to simply guess when they arrived or when they began their online tasks, and owners will stop paying for time that they weren’t working.

At SwipeClock, we help businesses save time and money with automated employee timekeeping and scheduling.

By Laura Marre

Simplify HR management today.

Simplify HR management today.

Employee Time Clocks for Small Business: The All-Encompassing Guide

February 27, 2024
Posted in , ,

Updated February 28, 2024 Tracking employee time is a vital aspect of managing a workforce properly. But knowing which type of clock to use or how to maintain the essential data can be challenging, especially for small business owners who are handling a long list of other tasks. Check out our guide to types of…

Read More
Photo by Jason Goodman

Start the New Year with a Commitment to the Employee Experience

January 2, 2024
Posted in , , ,

As a small business owner, you may not give a lot of thought to the experience of each employee within your organization. After all, you probably have a lot of other tasks on your to-do list, including growing your business. But what you may not realize is that failing to consider the experience of every…

Read More

WorkforceHub takes care of business.

We’ll show you how.

Request a Demo - Footer Form

Looking for help? Please click here.

brand - dots