Employers Should Learn From Family Medical Leave Act Lawsuit

FMLA lawsuit serves as warning to employers
Avatar photo


HR tech that powers small businesses. Get in, get the job done and keep your business moving with an easy to use solution for time, HR and benefits.

Communication Leaves Employer in Court over FMLA Lawsuit

The only thing that was needed to keep FX Direct out of an employment dispute and the ensuing lawsuit was adequate communication and notifications.

The employer’s handbook contained two separate sections. One section referred to 12 weeks of Family Medical Leave Act leave and another section titled “maternity leave.” The maternity leave section referred to 8 weeks of paid leave, followed by the option to take an additional 4 weeks of unpaid leave. Both sections failed to state that maternity leave would occur simultaneously with FMLA leave.

The employee submitted a formal request for time off through email titled “Maternity leave.” She asked to use her vacation first and then the maternity leave that was specified in the handbook.

After taking the 12 weeks of maternity leave, the employee stayed on leave, believing that her FMLA leave would then begin. She states that she tried to reach out to her employer multiple times for clarification and confirmation, but did not get a response.

After she failed to return to work at the end of the first 12 weeks, she was fired.

The lawsuit claims that her firing is in violation of her FMLA leave, which started after her 12 weeks of maternity leave.

However, the HR manager has stated that according to her experience in other jobs, both maternity and FMLA leave should run consecutively.

This is where the water gets muddy for the employer. While the HR manager assumed concurrent leaves, her manager, a VP, assumed otherwise. The VP manager testified that she thought the leaves would run consecutively. This shows an unclear policy even within the management of the company.  

FMLA Penalties Nearly Certain

If FMLA leave is considered to have run consecutively with the employer’s maternity leave, then the employer would likely be liable for fines for failure to disclose and notify the employee of FMLA leave.

However, if it is determined that FMLA leave ran consecutively and started after the employee’s maternity leave, then the employer would be subject to the fines and restitution required under FMLA law.

These fines, penalties and possible retribution is in addition to the legal costs the employer is already facing to defend themselves in court and in addition to the public reputation loss the employer has suffered.

Failure to Provide FMLA Notice, a Warning to Employers

The failure for FX Direct to communicate with the employee shows how vital it is that employers have both formal and informal communication with employees regarding FMLA leave. In fact, notification is a vital component to FMLA leave.

FMLA rules require that employers not only provide notice regarding FMLA rights, but also regarding leave approvals. FMLA requires that within 5 days of the initial leave request employers provide notice of the employee’s eligibility. Another rule states that employees don’t have to specifically request FMLA leave to be protected under the law.

In this example, the employee did not request FMLA leave until she looked forward to starting FMLA as her maternity leave expired. If the employer considered her maternity leave to be running concurrently with FMLA leave, then she should have been informed that the leaves would run concurrently. She should have been provided with a notice of FMLA leave and eligibility within 5 days of her request for maternity leave.

Concurrent Leave is an Option for Employers

Many employers choose to run employer benefit leaves concurrently with FMLA leave or other state leave laws. In fact many state sick leave and FMLA laws are written for specific instances of concurrent coverage.

However, it is vital that policies regarding leave be clearly defined in the employee handbook.

It is also imperative that employers clearly communicate concerning concurrent leaves to employees and remember to provide FMLA eligibility notice within days of the employee requesting leave.

Even if the employee did not request FMLA leave, it may count as FMLA leave if it qualifies under FMLA rules and if the employee is notified that FMLA leave is being taken.

For now, DX Direct and their former employee will continue onto a jury trial where it will be decided whether or not FMLA leave and the employee’s reinstatement rights were violated.

Let SwipeClock Help

Fortunately, HR technology can be a great asset for employers who are seeking a way to seamlessly track and provide notice to employees. Regulatory compliance becomes easy and affordable through SwipeClock’s award winning software.

In addition to all the local and state laws many businesses have to comply with, these businesses have to also comply with Federal Overtime Laws, the Family Medical Leave Act and any other national or local laws that are enacted.

SwipeClock provides a comprehensive array of workforce management and time tracking tools that can help businesses to more easily stay in compliance with local and national laws.

Records are effortlessly kept for years and accrual is automatically tracked and reported to employees according to the state and city laws. Additionally, with geo-timekeeping clocks, businesses can effortlessly track time worked in specific cities to ensure compliance.


FMLA Fact Sheet #28D Employer Notification

Rengan vs FX Direct

Written by Annemaria Duran. Last updated on August 16, 2017

Simplify HR management today.

Simplify HR management today.

Compliance with FMLA featuring a mother and newborn

The Most Common FMLA Compliance Mistake Made by Small Business Owners

October 17, 2023
Posted in

Updated October 18, 2023 As a small business owner, you work hard to balance your time between growing your business and managing your workforce. Among laws around labor and compliance, FMLA is usually one of high focus, as the penalties are costly and violations common. But what’s the biggest and most common mistake made by…

Read More
Photo by Christina Morillo

11 Reasons for Leaving a Job: Most Common, What’s Appropriate?

October 10, 2023
Posted in , ,

Employee turnover is a significant issue that impacts organizations of all sizes and across every industry. A recent Forbes article outlined some surprising statistics, including the cost associated with replacing an employee who leaves their role. (Spoiler alert: It’s a third of their salary). Explore 11 of the most common reasons for leaving a job,…

Read More

WorkforceHub takes care of business.

We’ll show you how.

Request a Demo - Footer Form

Looking for help? Please click here.

brand - dots