Disney to pay 3.8 Million for Payroll & Timekeeping Violations
Walt Disney Resorts to pay back wages, overtime pay, and the price of inaccurate timekeeping records.
Walt Disney will pay 16,339 employees back wages that total 3.8 million dollars. The US Department of Labor (DOL) officials found that Disney violated employment law regarding minimum wage, overtime, and timekeeping requirements.
The Department says that Disney cooperated with their investigation.
The affected divisions of Disney are the Disney Vacation Club Management Corp, and the Walt Disney Parks and Resorts, including the Florida Disney World.
The agreement covers alleged violations between 2013 and 2017 and states that Disney is not admitting to any violations.
“This is a very large amount of money, but even more important because a large number of workers were involved,” said Seth Harris, who served as acting secretary of labor under President Barack Obama. “This case is another illustration of the fact that wage and hour enforcement is just as critical today as it ever has been.”
What happens when employers deduct employee costumes, dropping wages below minimum wage:
According to the DOL, Disney deducted some employee’s wages for costumes and those deductions caused the employees to earn below the Federal $7.25 minimum wage.
Although the newest Federal Overtime Rule updates are pending an outcome in Federal Court, it is still important for employers to make efforts to ensure compliance with overtime law. The Department of Labor has continued to increase fines for overtime violations, many of which occur when employers fail to realize overtime worked and then fail to pay for it.
Timekeeping mistakes: Post-shift and Pre-Shift duties
In addition, some employees were identified as performing pre-shift or post-shift duties before or after their shifts ended and off the clock. According to employment law, employees should be paid for all labor performed, and companies are held responsible, even when the employee performs these duties without the employer’s knowledge.
Often, however, a culture of expectation is created where employees may feel that they are expected to do certain things off the clock.
“These violations are not uncommon and are found in other industries as well,” said Daniel White, district director for the Wage and Hour Division in Jacksonville, Fla. “Employers cannot make deductions that take workers below the minimum wage and must accurately track and pay for all the hours their employees work, including any time they work before and after shifts.
While that sounds logical and easy to maintain on a corporate level, it isn’t always. For example, many employers and managers don’t realize that often employees should be paid for the time spent getting into required uniforms at the place of business because that isn’t typically thought of as “working.”
Disney is only one of many large companies to pay for the same mistakes
Last year, for example, Gerber paid a 3 Million dollar fine for labor violations. The violation: not paying employees for the time spent donning and doffing their uniforms. Employees alleged that they weren’t paid for the time spent putting on their uniforms, using a lint roller, or the time spent walking to their assigned workstations.
Often employers assume that employees should be required to come to the start of their shift dressed and ready to work. Yet that line gets a little blurry when employees are required to wear specific uniforms.
According to the Department of Labor, when employees are required to spend time to maintain a uniform, then that time and the time spent getting ready in the uniform are part of the employee’s paid time.
That makes it vital for employers to have the right types of policies around employee timekeeping and to have the right equipment in place, for example, having timeclocks by the changing rooms and not 5 minutes away at the workstations.
Timekeeping training to managers and non-exempt employees is vital
Another aspect is making sure that managers and employees alike understand when to clock in and start their shift.
Disney will have to initiate better training around this area.
As part of Disney’s agreement with the DOL, Disney has 30 days to start training all managers, supervisors and non-exempt employees at all of its Florida resort hotels “on what constitutes compensable work time and the need to accurately record all such time.”
Lack of records creates an assumption of guilt
Another part of Disney’s record and timekeeping violation was having inadequate records. This is becoming a larger and more expensive mistake for companies to make. Thousands of companies still use manual timekeeping records.
Studies have shown that manual records are lost over 10 times more often than electronic records and are much more easily manipulated and fraudulently altered, often by the employees.
Often Federal and individual State Labor Laws are written with a clause that assumes employer guilt in the absence of adequate records. In other words, unless an employer has detailed enough records to prove that a violation did not occur, the employer will usually be found guilty of violating labor laws.
Although Disney hasn’t commented on the types of timekeeping methods or records retention policy that they have in place, it is most likely that at least part of their timesheets are being kept through employees noting their time and not through a punch clock or a biometric clock, where employee physical sign in at the beginning of their shift.
“The Department of Labor has identified a group of cast members who may have performed work outside of their scheduled shift , and we will be providing a one-time payment to resolve this.” A Walt Disney spokeswoman told Reuters.
Disney also stated that they will be adjusting their procedures to avoid the same type of labor violations in the future.
Certainly those procedures will now include, not only better training around timekeeping, but also better timekeeping methods.
Paul DeCamp, who ran the wage and hour division under President George W. Bush said that unpaid work before or after an employee’s shift, uniform deductions that bring pay below the minimum wage, and incorrect record-keeping are all issues that arise fairly often in employment law enforcement.
Three things your company can do to avoid similar violations
- Make sure that you have a policy in place that clearly states when employees clock in and out and that it includes all pre-shift and post-shift activities such as prepping uniforms and workstations for the shift.
- Regularly publish or train managers and employees on proper timekeeping procedure. When to clock in and out of a shift and make sure that all employees understand that “working off the clock” is not an acceptable practice.
- Have automatic timekeeping technology that automatically tracks and retains employee records. Although manual timesheets are allowed by law, studies have shown that businesses lose an average of 4.5 hours of lost wages from employees admitting to falsifying time records. Additionally, manual records are more easily lost and often fail to record important information that is needed in a labor dispute.
Simplify HR management today.
A new sick and safe time law will go into effect on January 1, 2024, impacting Minnesota employers. The Minnesota sick and safe time law requires employers to provide paid leave to eligible employees who work in the state. To qualify for paid leave, employees must work at least 80 hours in a year for…Read More
Updated October 18, 2023 As a small business owner, you work hard to balance your time between growing your business and managing your workforce. Among laws around labor and compliance, FMLA is usually one of high focus, as the penalties are costly and violations common. But what’s the biggest and most common mistake made by…Read More